How We Verify and Review

This is the written method behind every address, status label and review on this site. It is deliberately specific, so a reader can see what a “verified” badge stands for and repeat the check without trusting us.

The Verification Loop, Step by Step

Every web address we publish goes through the same sequence. The sequence is short on purpose, because a check that takes an hour does not get repeated.

  1. Collect the operator's own announcement from the channel the operator uses for it, and keep a copy of the signed text.
  2. Verify the PGP signature on that text against the operator's published public key. If the signature does not validate, the text is treated as unsigned and nothing in it is published.
  3. Compare the address inside the signed text with the address we are about to publish, character by character.
  4. Open the address and look at what loads: the sign-in page, any personal confirmation phrase the service uses, and whether the site behaves the way the signed announcement describes.
  5. Record the date of the check on the page. The date belongs to the check, not to the page edit.

How Sources Are Weighted

A review draws on three kinds of source, and they do not carry equal weight. Signed material from the operator settles what the operator says. Public reporting, including press releases from law-enforcement agencies, settles dates and events. Community feedback is treated as a lead and never as proof.

When two kinds of source disagree, the entry is held rather than published with a guess. A conflict between a signed announcement and community reports is often the most informative thing a review can surface, so it is stated on the page when it cannot be resolved.

What the Status Labels Mean

The same few labels appear in the comparison table and on every review, and each has one meaning.

  • Online, re-confirmed on a date: the signed address was checked against the live site on that date and matched. It says nothing about any later day.
  • Closed after the operator stopped paying out: the address is removed from the page, but the entry stays so a reader who searches the old name gets a plain answer.
  • Seized: law enforcement took control of the site. Any address still presented under that name afterwards is a clone.
  • Closed without explanation: the service shut without an announcement or a confirmed cause. We say that the cause is unknown instead of inventing one.

What We Examine in a Review

The headings differ from page to page because the platforms differ, but the same questions are asked of each one.

  • Which currencies are accepted, and whether Monero is supported or required.
  • How escrow works, and whether the operator can move funds out of an open order alone.
  • How accounts are protected: PGP login confirmation, personal phrases, whether the site works with JavaScript disabled.
  • What data the platform keeps, and how long the operator has been running it.
  • What the record shows: seizures, closures, outages and unresolved complaints.

The Limits of Any Single Check

A verified address is a statement about one moment. It does not predict a closure, it does not rate any seller, and it cannot protect a reader who skips the signature check on the next visit. Clones appear daily, so we treat a dated check as a reference point and say so on the page.

We do not vouch for individual sellers or listings, we do not publish seller lists, and we do not describe tests we did not run. Where we could not check something, the review says that it was not checked.

Running the Same Check Yourself

The method only counts if a reader can reproduce it. The PGP signature guide walks through the signature step, and the browser setup guide covers the rest. The independence rules that sit behind the method, and how mistakes are corrected, are set out in the editorial policy.